Genre: Fantasy Fiction, Dark Fantasy

Rating: 4

Unveiling the Depths of Hell and Heart

Kate Callaghan’s “Crowned A Traitor” is a dark fantasy that takes readers on a tumultuous journey through the realms of Hell to the mystical lands of Kalos. Published in July 2020 and obtained as an ARC from NetGalley, this novel serves up a complex concoction of power, betrayal, and a quest for freedom that is both enchanting and bewildering.

The Central Saga: Klara & The Throne of Hell

At the heart of this narrative is Klara, heir to the ominous throne of Hell and the Dark Forest of Malum. Her destiny, seemingly etched in the shadows of her lineage, is to ascend as the High Queen of Malum. However, Klara rebels against this. She’s scared that once she does ascend, it will only be a matter of time before someone kills her. It’s also that she doesn’t want to be queen. As a typical young adult, Klara would like to figure out her place in life instead of abiding by other people’s expectations of her. So, her tale is not just about a throne but about the essence of freedom and the weight of expectations.

Klara’s relationship with Frendall is one of the book’s focal points, showcasing a complicated friendship teetering on the brink of romantic entanglement. Their bond, while deep, lacks the electrifying charge of destined lovers, feeling more like a profound connection marred by circumstances and unspoken truths. The narrative toys with the idea of love’s ultimate sacrifice, drawing parallels with Lilith’s past decisions, yet it falls short of convincing us of the gravity between Klara and Frendall. Nevertheless, there’s a twist at the end: you must read the book to enjoy this one.

A Web of Intrigue and Deception

Lilith’s ominous warning about Frendall and Mila’s ambitions throws a shadow of doubt over Frendall’s intentions. It’s a classic narrative twist, leaving readers to ponder if Klara’s allies are as trustworthy as they appear. This uncertainty is a double-edged sword, adding tension while also muddling the clarity of character motivations.

Character Flaws and Moral Quandaries

Klara’s journey is fraught with personal and ethical dilemmas. Her struggle with her identity, symbolized by her white wings and her father’s rejection, reveals the complexities of family and acceptance. Yet, Klara’s character sometimes veers into selfish territory, her longing for freedom overshadowing the consequences of her actions. This trait makes her human and relatable but also frustrating, especially as the narrative progresses toward its climax.

Reflections on Borders and Freedom

The narrative revisits the theme of borders, both literal and metaphorical. The proposition to use borders to determine worthiness and safety echoes contemporary debates, albeit with a fantastical twist. It’s a contentious point that seems to resonate less with the themes of personal liberty and more with a contrived solution to deeper societal divides.

Final Verdict

“Crowned A Traitor” is a dark fantasy that explores the burdens of legacy, the quest for self-determination, and the murky waters of trust and betrayal. While the emotional depth between Klara and Frendall might not reach the heights of epic romance, the story compels with its rich world-building and moral complexities. It’s a tale for those who relish in the shadows of power, the light of rebellion, and the gray areas of the heart.